Thousands around the world log on to see falcons

Frosty talons on a chilly Nottingham morning

Frosty talons on a chilly Nottingham morning

Although the falcon eggs aren’t expected to hatch until the end of April, since the launch of Falcon Cam 2013 visitors from around the globe have logged on to watch and read about our resident pair of peregrine falcons.

We’ve registered visitors from countries as far and wide as Australia, America, Russia, India, South Africa, Saudi Arabia,  Thailand, Taiwan, Indonesia, Iraq, Argentina and many, many more.

More than 220,000 people have logged onto the cameras to watch the birds sat up high on the Newton building, while one of the birds has remained firmly sat on her eggs to keep them warm during incubation.  On average, each visitor spent an average of six minutes and 47 seconds watching the cameras.

There have been visitors from 99 different countries.  After the UK, the most common countries for visitors are America, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Spain and France.

The peak number of blog readers since the 2013 launch was on Monday 25 March, with more than 4,600 unique readers. It’s surely no coincidence that this influx followed a weekend of snow which caused much concern among the doting Falcon Cam viewers, many of whom were worried for the birds’ wellbeing.

News of the falcons’ three eggs being laid ahead of Easter made the headlines, with stories appearing in the Scotsman as well as regional newspapers the Eastern Daily Press, the Hartlepool Mail, Northern Echo, Sunderland Echo, Western Daily Press and more.

BBC Springwatch presenter Martin Hugh-Games also mentioned the project in an article in the Daily Telegraph. And the picture at the top of this blog, which was taken by one of our members of staff, was circulated to the media by the Press Association.

Interviews with people from the university and Nottinghamshire Wildlife Trust also took place with BBC Radio Nottingham and a story was published on the BBC Nottingham web pages.

We may expect another surge of visitors to the cameras in the not too distant future. If the eggs do hatch before the end of the month, it will surely lead to thousands of people logging on in the hope of seeing new-born falcon chicks.

Although we’re yet to discover whether the wintry weather took any toll on the eggs, the anticipation of new chicks will surely create a great deal of excitement. Let’s just hope this year provides less of an emotional rollercoaster than last.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

163 Responses to Thousands around the world log on to see falcons

  1. Valerie Willsher says:

    Watching around 9.20am this morning (16th) i saw a 3rd falcon arrive at the far end of the ledge. Could this have been last year’s chick? The 2nd bird seemed aware it was there but quite unfazed.

    Like

  2. Glynne Watson says:

    I like many other webcam viewers watching over the snowy period was very concerned for the birds welfare.I posted your picture of the falcon covered in snow and it has been retweeted all over the world that.That bird is one tough cookie I cannot wait for the eggs to hatch and the real action to begin.

    Like

  3. Lynn says:

    Mmm I thought that is what I saw- but then thought perhaps it was just a brave pigeon!

    Like

  4. libby says:

    world wide super stars

    Like

  5. S says:

    I looked out my back window today and my heart nearly stopped….there were two raptors sitting in the big tree in my yard. I thought they were falcons at first (they do nest in the area) but upon closer inspection through the binoculars it turns out they are Cooper’s Hawks. I got to see them mate, as I was watching them, and then watched them fly to a nearby nest. Not peregrines…but still interesting to see out my back window. XD

    Like

    • SueAtt says:

      S – never heard of a Cooper’s Hawk so I Googled it and discovered that they are native to North America – so I presume that you must be one of the many worldwide ‘viewers’ of the Nottingham Peregrins? 🙂

      Like

      • S says:

        Yes, Sue, I am in Niagara Falls, Canada. 🙂

        It’s a good spot for birdwatching…we have lots of raptors; turkey vultures, Ospreys, a variety of hawks, owls, eagles, and falcons…plus a variety of songbirds of course, and lots of waterfowl varieties; I love the Great Blue Herons. One of my favourite birds to watch is the Kingfisher. Hilarious little birds. Big surge in woodpecker numbers, this year, too, and in recent years I’ve even spotted Baltimore Orioles, which is interesting.

        We have a pair of falcons nesting in the Niagara Gorge that have received quite a bit of press in recent years (No cam, sorry!) and when I was driving past the Falls several days ago, one of them suddenly flew up out of the gorge and passed maybe 12 feet above my car!! It was a real treat to see one so close….I got a great look at it!! XD

        I also watch the falcon cam at Great Spirit Bluff, Minnesota, and I also watched the Decorah Eagles in Iowa last year (although this year they outsmarted us and built a new nest…no cam.) So instead I have been keeping an eye on the Minnesota Bound Eagle cam.

        but I love the Nott cam….I watched the bad weather last year and this year, too. Storm really has a great advantage with that long ledge to practice with, on the Newton bldg.

        Like

  6. SueAtt says:

    Mrs P (I think) sitting quietly on the nest – well sheltered from this terrible wind that seems to have been battering us for ever!

    Like

  7. libby says:

    does anyone know if there is going to be a fourth egg or not

    Like

  8. Martyn says:

    Bit concerned that she laid the eggs in the scratch that was 3″ deep in snow. Could this have killed the eggs? I know the birds are tough cookies, i guess we will see in a week or so!

    Like

    • S says:

      I am no expert, and I worried about this, along with everyone else, here. But I personally comfort myself with the thought that these are mountain birds, very tough, and they’ve probably faced such obstacles, and worse, many times before.

      I suspect that as long as there is an adult sitting on the eggs, they are warm enough; snow can also act as a very effective insulator, too.

      What concerned me more was that during the bad weather, I noticed that there was one night where there was no adult on the nest for a period of about three hours…which I can’t help but imagine might put the eggs at risk for freezing. But I don’t wish to worry anyone….I just trust that nature knows best…and we won’t know until it’s time for hatching, anyway, so we’ll just have to watch and wait and keep our fingers crossed, I suppose.

      Like

  9. Lynn says:

    Don’t know what happened just now- alot of squawking- looked in to see the sitting bird flying off and leaving eggs. Two minutes later a bird(same one?) was back on eggs. Often see them changing over but this was different- repelling enemies?

    Like

  10. Dave Carder says:

    Who controls the camera ? Just looked and it was zooming in on a piece of loft insulation blown into the gulley

    Like

    • gillyntu says:

      Hi Dave,
      A number of staff at NTU have control of the camera. We were taking a closer look as we couldn’t work out what it was from a distance. All back in place now 🙂

      Like

  11. chris morley says:

    get ready folks thursday should be the day for 1st chick me thinks

    Like

  12. Chessie Davies says:

    I watch on a daily basis now; with my morning coffee, during my lunch break, and my tea o’clock afternoon break. My sank when I saw all the snow and thought we’d lost the one of the falcons and the eggs. Keeping my fingers crossed that we have some hatchlings after all this weather stress!

    Like

  13. Ian says:

    Has the “nest scrape” moved slightly to the right?

    Like

  14. S says:

    I see Mrs. P’s garden patch is growing back, in the box. lol

    Like

  15. S says:

    Something sounds like screaming or crying…not sure if it’s a person, below, machinery, or an animal or bird. Sure sounds mournful, though.

    Like

  16. S says:

    Oh it’s people. I can hear them now.

    Like

  17. John Jones says:

    Just watching the female standing over the eggs and she appeared to be eating something, however the shadow was on her and couldnt see properly. I was thinking it may be a bit of egg shell and one had hatched. Fingers crossed eh !! The male was also close by watching tentatively so hoping for some good news later today or tomorrow

    Like

  18. Geoff Pickering says:

    The really close-up shots yesterday were amazing, can we have more of them please. How is S able to hear sounds? I have tried but unsuccessfully.

    Like

    • gillyntu says:

      Hi Geoff, pleased that you like the shots, we’ll do our best to keep track of the birds, especially once the chicks hatch and become mobile.
      Camera 2 (the one fixed on the nest) has sound, you may need to have your computer volume turned up a bit higher to get a good sound level. It will become very noisy once the parents start bringing food for the chicks!

      Like

    • S says:

      I’m sorry, Geoff, I didn’t see your question till just now. I wasn’t ignoring you.

      Yes, as gillyntu said, Camera 2 has sound on it, but you have to make sure that both your computer’s sound is turned up (test with music, or something)
      AND,
      you also have to ensure that the little volume control *on the cam window* is turned up (icon is located in the bottom right-hand corner of the cam-window, between the timer and the “expand window” icon).

      If it still doesn’t work, I don’t know. Hope it helps!

      Like

  19. kathryn says:

    should i confess, i have both camera one and camera two open on two different pages, its quicker to see whats going off, switching tabs rather than cameras, if there is a lot of noise from the nest bird, the partner is often close by …

    Like

    • Geoff says:

      A smart idea Kathryn, why hadn’t I thought of that too.

      Like

    • grantntu says:

      Thanks for your dedicated following Kathryn. Due to the popularity of Falcon Cam we would actually prefer viewers to just load the page when they want to watch, rather than leave it on in the background. This is because it obviously uses lots of our bandwidth having the continuous video streams. In periods of high uptake there is a risk we may have to lower the picture quality to maintain the feed. So if you could just load it when you want to watch that would be a great help!
      Thanks.

      Like

  20. chris morley says:

    get ready folks tomoz is the day,its only my opinion but its my wifes birthday so im hoping for another birth on this day

    Like

    • Tracy Downes says:

      Noooooo! I wont be at a pc tomorrow until about 5pm, she needs to cross her legs and hang on until I’m ready!!!I’m hooked on this pair, so fascinating to watch.

      Like

  21. Jenny Martin says:

    Just seen the 3 eggs again as Mrs P was doing some housekeeping around the nest

    Like

  22. freda says:

    Pa has landed in the ledge but staying well back – no food evident – looking around (for handy pigeon?)
    Ma sitting stoically

    Like

  23. chris morley says:

    apprantly my mate says the greenery in box is a VERY rare plant he only knows the proper name for it”peregrineuss platformuss weedeuos ? ant got one in my garden thats for sure

    Like

  24. That nestbox looks lovely and tidy, must be ready for the pitter patter of tiny feet 😛

    Like

  25. Chessie says:

    Still three whole eggs from the little glimpse I got just then!

    Like

  26. Pam Birley. says:

    The falcon is fidgety and appears to be listening….maybe things are happening. They can hear their chicks cheeping in the egg. I would have thought 27-30th would be more likely timing for the first hatch but ….any time now !!!!

    Like

  27. Christine says:

    Just caught a brief glimpse of all 3 eggs – still intact – one egg hatched at Charing Cross – can see egg shell on the ledge, here’s hoping for Nottingham

    Like

  28. Billybags says:

    19-22pm she has still got all three eggs, all in tack.No sign of them being cracked. She has just got off them and turned around and then shuffled back on. Bitting my nails. She does seem a little restless.

    Like

  29. Christine says:

    Just seen 3 chicks being fed at Charing Cross – beautiful ! Come on Nottingham !

    Like

  30. Alison says:

    I was convinced we would see the first chick today, so I logged on while having breakfast only to be rewarded by the sight of Mrs P coughing up a pellet!

    Like

  31. Keyworth Red says:

    11;20am, still 3 eggs, no chicks yet…

    Like

  32. S says:

    Just had a good look at the eggs. No definite signs of a pip yet.

    Like

  33. chris morley says:

    sorry for delay folks,forgot to enter in snow at time of laying ?? you get slow when yer past yer prime,anyway looks like tomoz now but good thing it will be weekend for more folk to see it live i ant stopped watching and have noticed male is doing MORE than his fair share on eggs,good on him,he will soon be very busy,get a break while yer can i say

    Like

  34. Dora Yemm says:

    I am a devout peregrine-watcher and I captured this clip earlier of one of them complaining about the loud sirens, so cute!

    Waiting for those eggs to hatch…

    Like

  35. Sarah says:

    6.41pm, just had a good look at the eggs when parent left for a few minutes. No action yet as far as I can tell.

    Like

  36. Trevor says:

    Just changed over still 3 eggs no chicks !!

    Like

  37. Charing Cross got three chicks and one egg still to hatch

    Like

  38. tim.t. says:

    I just seen the cam spin around to see there feeding platform on the corner of the building this is a important part of the study of these birds to see how they feed, & just how many birds get eaten & what type of bird they take the most ,Do you not think that your tec guys can get the cam next to were they feed on the website…????

    Like

  39. Dora Yemm says:

    The parent left for a few minutes about an hour ago (12:30), so I looked at the eggs but couldn’t see any cracks or anything…

    Like

  40. brian says:

    when was the last time the male was seen? can someone please say?
    thanks

    Like

  41. Nick says:

    20:17 – shift change – still three intact eggs. Without wishing to sound pessimistic, how long before we must concede that the eggs are not viable?

    Like

  42. Nick says:

    Another shift change……. still 3 eggs and no chicks 😦

    Like

    • Pam Birley says:

      Nick, I don’t think you should be despondent. Hatching could be any time in the next 2/3 days based on the estimated date of them settling to brood. I feel hopeful that if we don’t get the extreme weather we had last year then we should have three healthy chicks quite soon. Maybe first hatch will be tomorrow so don’t have a Sunday morning lie-in 🙂

      Like

  43. gail says:

    my brother told me about this sight i am besotted with the falcons what beautiful birds i love to watch them

    Like

  44. Billybags says:

    Sunday 7.26am noisy change over. Still got three eggs in tack.

    Like

  45. Trevor says:

    Still 3 eggs no chicks just stood up to rearrange eggs

    Like

  46. Christine says:

    Does anyone at NTU know which day full incubation commenced ? The nest site was covered with snow on the 25th march with the falcon sitting tight – that makes it day 34 today – do you think the sub zero temperatures could have delayed the incubation even though the eggs were not left unattended ? Or are we all being a bit impatient !

    Like

  47. Keyworth Red says:

    She seems very restless this morning 9:14am, hope its a good sign..

    Like

  48. Nick says:

    Still 3 eggs but Mrs P is very busy rearranging stones around the scrape…. Preparing for a new arrival?…… Let’s hope so 🙂

    Like

  49. Geoff says:

    Shift changeover at 12.25pm today, still 3 eggs intact

    Like

  50. San says:

    12.25 Shift change. 3 eggs still intact .

    Like

  51. Richard says:

    The eggs will have commenced full time incubation latest 26th March.The incubation period is usually 28 to 30 days resulting in a hatch date of the 25th April. We are now three days late,it is looking very unlikely that they are viable.

    Like

  52. Pam Birley says:

    First egg is pipping !!! Pic here:
    First egg is pipping !

    Like

  53. Adele says:

    Hi thought I just saw a crack on egg nearest to us

    Like

  54. chris morley says:

    still no chicks at aylsbury,norwich,sheffield,chichester either everyones waiting

    Like

  55. S says:

    PIP!!! I saw at least one DEFINITE PIP!! …possibly two more, starting, too 😀

    Like

  56. S says:

    …sorry, it was during a changeover.

    Like

  57. S says:

    It’s my birthday today, too….what a nice birthday present, to see a pip in these eggs when we were all so scared after the bad weather!!! Does that mean the falcons share a birthday with me???
    😀

    Like

  58. Kay and Dex says:

    I think I can see a crack in two of the eggs? Anyone else catch that?!

    Like

  59. Adele says:

    I did!! as she got up there was a small hole she then kicked it over when she left its now upside down poor chick didnt anyone else see it or the staff watching it!!!

    Like

  60. Sheena says:

    14.49 shift change, not sure if it’s me but none of the eggs are as vbrant in colour as they were and the one at the back looked decidedly grotty. I hope they are all okay and the chicks inside are healthy and just waiting to say hello to the world.

    Like

  61. damian says:

    There will definitely be a chick or 2 by tonight judging by all the activity…

    Like

  62. Mg says:

    Definatley chipping at 17.17. Egg at the back

    Like

  63. San says:

    17.17 shift change. DEFINITELY saw a small hole in one of the eggs 🙂

    Like

  64. Sheena says:

    17.20 change over, mum gone to stretch her wings, still no chicks but the eggs didn’t look as bad as I thought earlier, it must have been the light.

    Like

  65. Adele says:

    i was right then , hi to all egg watchers here in my own town of Nottingham

    Like

  66. Adele says:

    Silly me City not Town

    Like

  67. tomsmum says:

    change over at 18.15 and it looked like 2 eggs where pipping! 🙂

    Like

  68. libby says:

    im confused now because people are saying that the hatched and some people are saying that they have not

    Like

  69. Dora Yemm says:

    Hatch little falcons, hatch! We’re all waiting to see you!

    Like

  70. tomsmum says:

    they hadnt hatched at 19.00.

    Like

  71. tomsmum says:

    just seen the comment on seeing a chick,iv been sat for the past couple of hours watching and theres definatly no chick out and about yet lol

    Like

    • Dora Yemm, NTU Student says:

      I know I haven’t seen one either… At least there’s two eggs pipping though which means they’ll hopefully hatch soon.

      Like

  72. Adele says:

    no chicks yet but it must be tonight surely just holes

    Like

  73. tim.t. says:

    3am mum eats egg shell

    Like

  74. PammyD says:

    One chick definitely out, as she’s eating the shell. 3am local

    Like

  75. Nick says:

    3:15am – There is at least one chick alive and kicking……. Phew 🙂

    Like

  76. Ken McCormick says:

    03:40am UK time, Female on nest appeared to be eating eggshell.

    Like

  77. Nick says:

    4:02am …Definitely one chick and two eggs. In this picture, the first chick is visible and mum has just kicked the egg shell out of the scrape.

    Like

  78. Sally says:

    Definitely shell in the nest!

    Like

  79. Ken McCormick says:

    04:26am UK time. Falcon has reversed direction on nest, and is eating egg shell again

    Like

  80. Ken McCormick says:

    05:27am UK time saw one chick.

    Like

  81. Christine says:

    I’m sure there is a small piece of egg shell on the gravel and there is alot of shuffling going on, the male came to the ledge a few minutes ago and it seemed as if they had a bit of a conversation and he left – can’t wait to get a glimpse if it is a chick

    Like

  82. Christine says:

    THERE IS ONE HATCHING NOW I’M NOT SEEING THINGS – YIPEE

    Like

  83. Alison says:

    I just caught a glimpse of a chick emerging from one of the eggs and I thought I also saw a second fluffy chick – 6.02am. At last!

    Like

  84. Cas says:

    6am and I’ve just seen one chick half way out of the egg and a glimpse of what appears to be something fluffy and white too – which may be a chick which has hatched earlier and has already dried off.

    Like

  85. Sally says:

    I have seen a chick!!!

    Like

  86. K says:

    Woke up at 3am and had a quick look, it looked like one was moving broken eggshell from underneath

    Like

  87. Ken McCormick says:

    06:30am UK time saw one chick again

    Like

  88. billybags says:

    6.38am I am possitive I have seen a chick. Wow

    Like

  89. Definitely One just seen… But I think she could have had a double hatch overnight, need her to get up properly now. I can’t tell you how relieved I am after that awful weekend of snow 🙂 Well done Mrs Notts

    Like

  90. PammyD says:

    Second chic now out! 6am

    Like

  91. Update at 7.07 am, there is one definite hatch and one almost hatched, its still in the shell but the shell is almost in half 🙂

    Like

  92. Mo Cole says:

    Well done Mrs P of Nottingham… Mo Cole x

    Like

  93. Joyce S says:

    Fantastic news!! The way that the falcon sat in her ice-bivouac just shows how hardy these birds are.

    Like

  94. patrick driscoll says:

    first egg hatched this morning at 0755,great news after they had after all that snow.

    Like

  95. Dora Yemm says:

    Is that a little white ball of fluff I saw :D?

    They’ve arrived!

    Like

  96. Ken McCormick says:

    08:02am UK time Adults change brooders, two chicks seen

    Like

  97. redtedng9 says:

    A cold and wet night in Nottingham ,but we have at least one new chick, and mum has just been removing an empty egg. For sure one of the most dedicated pair of parents will continue to care for their young. Great news and marvellous to watch these superb birds in the middle of our city.

    Like

  98. Sarah says:

    Just seen 2 chicks, 3rd egg still looked intact.

    Like

  99. Jan says:

    Mr & Mrs P have just done a swap (8.05am) & there are definitely 2 chicks!

    Like

  100. Hetty says:

    Just saw one – it was all white and fluffy, bless it! It’s fine as well because it was moving it’s head. Mrs P was pushing the egg shell out of the way. She’s very fidgety this morning, so definitely action going on there!

    Like

  101. Belinda says:

    Just had a good view of 2 white fluffy chicks during handover at 8.03. Very sweet.

    Belinda

    Like

  102. patrick driscoll says:

    made a mistake with last comment,seen 2 chicks this morning after farther took over from mother,still great news.

    Like

  103. Trevor says:

    Just changed over could only see one egg and a lot of white fluffy feathers

    Like

  104. John says:

    Great to see good news,please remember not to keep your browser open all the time,as lots of people want to see 🙂

    Like

  105. Margaret says:

    Have only seen one chick ,do they hatch at the same time

    Like

  106. Nick says:

    The first chick hatched some time before 3:15am. I posted a picture but for some reason it has not be passed by the moderator 😦

    Like

    • Dave90 says:

      2 chicks at 0848

      Like

    • Nick says:

      Thanks moderator for passing it this time. The first chick had hatched some time before 3:15am. I caught seveal glimpses of the chick after that but I had to sit with my finger on the print screen button until 4:02am to get the picture you see above.

      Like

  107. San says:

    09.25 DELIGHTED to have just seen two little heads under Mrs P. Champagne chilling to enjoy tonight! It has been traumatic viewing at times over the last few weeks. Now the fun really starts!
    Thank you so much for this cam. The clarity is amazing.

    Like

  108. billybags says:

    DEFINITLY two chicks there. The other one must be hiding. They seemed quite big.

    Like

  109. San says:

    09.54 Not 100% but think I just saw what appears to be a small hole in the remaining egg.

    Like

  110. Damian Taylor says:

    10am Definately saw two chicks as she was shuffling about.

    Like

  111. Damian Taylor says:

    10:05am Third egg is definately pipping as got a good clear view of it..

    Like

  112. tomsmum says:

    how long before they feed from hatching?

    Like

  113. Pam Birley says:

    Two chicks, one egg. Congratulations NTU – you are mommas and poppas once again !
    April 29, 2013 - two chicks hatched overnight !

    Like

  114. Diane says:

    yessssssssssss 2 chicks 🙂

    Like

  115. annette says:

    just seen one chick being fed but other one didn’t get any is this normal first time on here

    Like

  116. Belinda says:

    Just seen 2 chicks being fed at 11:10. One at the back didn’t get much. Very cute.

    Belinda

    Like

  117. annette says:

    just seen some eggshell that I hadn’t seen earlier wondering if 3rd chick has hatched

    Like

  118. Dora Yemm says:

    OMG when they were feeding I saw one of them fall over! It was so cute! Haha!

    Like

  119. Hetty says:

    I’m so pleased Mrs P has been rewarded after all her hours of patient sitting – even being completely buried in snow! Now the hard work starts!!

    Like

  120. Dora Yemm says:

    Here’s some captures I got of the new chicks! When the mother’s leaving in the first clip one chick gets blown over by her wings flapping (or just by being off-balance), and then they drift into a gentle slumber. Hope you like the clips, sorry about the watermarks!

    Like

  121. john says:

    2 chicks and 3rd egg is hatching

    Like

  122. S says:

    Just got to watch a changeover and feeding. Two lovely little healthy chicks, and no doubt about it… definite pip in the third egg; could even clearly see movement inside!! 😀

    Like

  123. Gill Web says:

    How exciting – babies having a feed and the third egg has a tiny opening in it… This is rivetting stuff.
    Welcome chicks & Good Luck X

    Like

  124. Genevieve says:

    Just watched them being fed – pigeon? One little guy got less than the other. Does this even out over time? An egg at the back with a small hole in it.

    Like

  125. San says:

    13.22 Watched both chicks being fed, then falling asleep against unhatched egg. What a privelige this is to have such a clear view. Once again, a big thank you.

    Like

  126. Sue Hall says:

    I also watched both chicks being fed, excellent pictures, thanks for that, such a privilege to see

    Like

  127. kathryn says:

    wow! thats just made my day!

    Like

  128. San says:

    17.05 Wow, Wow, Wow! Was lucky enough to check in right at the moment chick number 3 hatched.
    Wathced as parent removed part of the cracked shell to reveal chick. She has been eating tiny pieces of the shell.

    Like

  129. Geoff says:

    7.03pm All 3 chicks on parade.

    Like

  130. Gill Web says:

    I’ve noticed that is very quiet – has the microphone been turned off or down? I was hoping to hear the chicks…?

    Like

  131. Sylvia says:

    Will we be able to see a recording of the chicks being ringed ?.

    Like

  132. Dave Carder says:

    I see the water is lapping the nest tray. a good job the chicks can move about onto ledges if it rains anymore. I fear if they were only days old that there could be a problem. A drain somewhere is obviously blocked.

    Like

Leave a reply to Ken McCormick Cancel reply